Review: The Wolf Wilder by Katherine Rundell

Posted August 10, 2015 by Lola in Historical, Review / 12 Comments


The Wolf WilderThe Wolf Wilder
by Katherine Rundell

Feodora and her mother live in the snowbound woods of Russia, in a house full of food and fireplaces. Ten minutes away, in a ruined chapel, lives a pack of wolves. Feodora’s mother is a wolf wilder, and Feo is a wolf wilder in training. A wolf wilder is the opposite of an animal tamer: it is a person who teaches tamed animals to fend for themselves, and to fight and to run, and to be wary of humans.

When the murderous hostility of the Russian Army threatens her very existence, Feo is left with no option but to go on the run. What follows is a story of revolution and adventure, about standing up for the things you love and fighting back. And, of course, wolves.

My Review:
I received a copy in exchange for an honest review

The Wolf Wilder wasn’t quite what I expected and I was actually a bit disappointed by it, the book has a great concept namely that of the Wolf Wilder and then spends a whole book not doing anything with that topic. Sure there were wolves around and I liked that, but there wasn’t much wilding taking place. It was more a quest around the countryside to save her mom, who was taken for no real reason, start a revolution and it was quite short and even a bit rushed at times and the other half things didn’t made quite sense. And even though it was short, it still felt slow and boring at times as well, while other parts weren’t fleshed out enough. There were scenes that didn’t really work or things that went too easy and were a tad unbelievable. Like the scene at the end. Although I did like the actual ending, I just thought the scene right before that was a bit unbelievable and too easy.

It was a shame I didn’t like it more, but it just fell flat for me. I wanted to see more wolf wilding, not a weird villain who hurts people and burns their homes for no reason at all. The ending had some nice build-up but was also a bit disturbing as they were so many kids involved and they teach those kids how to fight and it just made me sad instead of rooting for them. Kids of 6 years old shouldn’t have to learn how to fight, they shoudl be out playing. And how could one day training prepare them for anything. It was just a bit unbelievable. I did like the message of fighting for what you love and how sometimes you need to be brave enough to do something, but the whole book fell a bit flat and I couldn’t bring myself to really care.

There are also places where it says illustrations here and I think those illustrations might actually have added some flavour to this book, so as this was an ARC I can’t say anything about that, just that the final version will apparently have illustrations. Also the writing and tone felt very distant. There is some animal cruelty and normally that would have me close to tears, especially with our rat dying while I was reading this book, but the writing was so distant, it didn’t move me. I didn’t really felt involved or close, but more like watching things from a distance. The story can be a bit dark and disturbing at times and I didn’t like the plot too much. I also didn’t really get why her mom was taking and why the villain did what he did. It just didn’t make sense to me. Why have a country with wolf wilders and then suddenly decide they shouldn’t wild the wolves anymore.

The characters were interesting enough. You have the main character who is surrounded by wolves which was pretty cool. And Illya who isn’t quite who he seems and there’s a nice twist later of what he becomes and then there is the charismatic Ariel, who wants a revolution. They were interesting enough to add some flavour and colour to the story and I liked that. I would’ve wished to get to know them a bit better though. I also liked the part the wolves played in this book, they were quite present and that was nice. Then there is the villain who is plain evil and maybe even a bit crazy, but he had no motive and I just wanted more out of it. He had no depth or reason for his actions, he just was a maniac, but no reason or story of how he got there and why.

When it comes to world building this book takes place in Russia and there are a few Russian words thrown in. I first thought one of the word was someone’s name and was quite confused until I figured out it was a russian word probably. I liked the setting and I felt like that part at least came alive with all the snow and how the main character knew how to survive in the harsh winter. There is enough descriptions to form a bit of an imagine about the setting. One thing that was a bit vague was when this story takes place, I actually think it’s in the past, but my knowledge of Russian history is too limited to tell when. When it comes to world building around the wilding, the concept was great, but only in the first few chapters there is some wilding and then for some reason someone wants them to stop wilding, while before that it is established why they do this and it just didn’t make sense. After that it’s a story of a wolf girl, but not a focus on the wilding aspect.

To conclude: this was a bit disappointing and not at all what I expected. I expected focus on wolf wilding, but instead it was a girl going on a quest to save her mom, accompanied by wolves. The wolves were cool, but the story and plot fell a bit flat. It was rushed at times, slow at others, short and unbelievable at other times. The plot didn’t quite make sense or how they went form A to B, it just felt a bit off. The characters are interesting, but the writing was too distant to really make me care about anything or anyone. Read this book if you want a book about kids standing up and fighting for what they love, a girl who has wolves travelling with her and a Russian setting. For me this book just felt a bit off and wasn’t what I expected.


The Bookdepository

How do you like your villains best? How evil should they be? Do you want to know their motives and past?


12 responses to “Review: The Wolf Wilder by Katherine Rundell

  1. If the villains are too evil, I definitely want to know their backstory. However, no matter what happened to someone’s past, I don’t believe it justifies someone’s evilness. Why not be a better person? That’s just my two cents. I’m sorry that this book disappointed you a little. I was actually attracted to the book cover.

    • Same here, I love the book cover, too bad the book wasn’t as good. And I agree that a past might not explain someone’s actions or excuse them. Although I do think knowing someone’s motives behind what he does, can bring it into another perspective. Else it just feels like being evil for the sake of that, which I guess also happens, but I would like to know why a villain is evil or does evil things.

  2. I would have expected more about the wolves considering the title, cover, and blurb focus on that so I get your disappointment. The rest sounds pretty exciting though not understanding the villain’s motives would make it hard to get into the story. I’ve read a few that for whatever reason, the book doesn’t engage me emotionally.

    Sorry this one didn’t live up to expectation.
    Sophia Rose recently posted…Sins of the Night by Sherrilyn Kenyon #Review #NeverEndingSeriesMy Profile

    • The part that were about the wolves were well done and interesting, but the focus wasn’t on them. I jsut had expected more about the wilding and how they live there, but they were moving around the country running and saving her mom most of the book. And the villain just seemed plain evil and crazy without reason or motive, I would’ve liked for him to have more depth and be less bad? It just felt a bit exaggerated.
      Lola recently posted…Review: The Wolf Wilder by Katherine RundellMy Profile

  3. When it comes to villains…it depends on the scenario and setting of the story. Some books you don’t really need a bad one…but then there are others, where it makes sense to have a villain that is pretty bad because it adds more to a story and really gives it that edge.
    Renee (@Addictofromance) recently posted…Grab It Tuesday–August 11My Profile

  4. So what you’re saying is, it should probably have been called “Wolves Milling Around Aimlessly” or “Wolves in the Russian Background”, which admittedly, may have drawn my interest even more 😉 I am sorry this one fell flat for you- I have been curious about it but.. I am not as much anymore now that there isn’t a ton to be curious about haha. As for villains, I DO like a backstory. I mean, it doesn’t excuse the villainy, but it DOES help to understand them- a lot of times, I cannot get behind a villain who is just mean for no apparent reason! Great review, hope the next book you read is a bit more exciting!
    Shannon @ It Starts At Midnight recently posted…Depression is a Silent Killer: A Guest Post by Michelle SmithMy Profile

    • Yes! “Wolves Milling Around Aimlessly” or “Wolves in the Russian Background” both would have been better fitting titles. lol I just had to laugh aloud at that. They both sound like good titles and fit the book better to be honest.
      It was just so sad there wasn’t more wolf wilding as I loved the concept. The wolves were pretty cool too, that was the part I liked most, but the svaing her mom and the rebellion was all a bit off.
      I also prefer to understand a villian. What I dislike most is whena villain seems evil just because he can or enjoys being evil. That seems to be the case here, he was evil and that was all we learn about him. His actions made no sense and didn’t seem to have a goal.

Leave a Reply

CommentLuv badge

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.