Review: Goat Magic by Kate Wheeler

Posted August 20, 2025 by Lola in Fantasy, Review, Romance / 4 Comments

Goat Magic
by Kate Wheeler

My Rating: 4 stars

Genre: Fantasy
Age Category: Young Adult
Type of romance: f/f

Blurb:
Destinies collide when a village goat herder meets the palace princess in Goat Magic!

Trill, a spirited goat herder with a unique ability to communicate with her flock, yearns for a life beyond mountain pastures. Her “goat magic” feels common compared to the sorcery taught in the city’s prestigious magic schools, which are off-limits to her. Meanwhile, Princess Alya, known as the “Ordinary Princess” and heir to the kingdom of Capeya, doubts her own royal potential.

Their worlds collide when an assassination attempt on the queen leaves Alya cursed to transform into a black goat each sunrise. Seeking refuge in Trill’s goat herd, Alya discovers her new friend’s hidden talent is her only hope to break the spell. Together, they embark on a perilous journey back to the castle, facing treacherous foes and uncovering a web of betrayal and rebellion.

As Alya battles to reclaim her throne and restore order to Capeya, the girls discover a deep connection, their shared experiences forging an unbreakable bond. When Alya comes face to face with the ones who betrayed her, will she have what it takes to take back the crown and rule an unstable kingdom? Will Trill find confidence in her magic and the growing affection she has for her friend?

With fast-paced action, enchanting magic, and a budding romance, Goat Magic is a captivating graphic novel perfect for fans of fantasy adventure.

My Review

I received a free copy from the publisher through Netgalley and voluntarily reviewed it. All opinions are my own.

This one caught my eye when I spotted it on Netgalley, the title and cover just sounded so fun and I knew I had to read it. I am so glad I got approved for it as I had a fun time reading this one. It’s a fun fantasy adventure type story following a goat herder with special magic that let her talk to her goats and a princess who gets cursed to turn into a goat during the day.

I liked Trill from the start, she’s just such a fun character with her goats and her magic and her desire to explore the world and do something more. She has some self esteem issues as she always was made to feel her magic and powers weren’t enough, but she does have a supportive mother. Alya is the princess of the kingdom, she is called the “Ordinary Princess”. She struggles really feeling like a princess and when she gets cursed to turn into a goat during the day and only be in her human form at night she meets Trill while she’s a goat and joins the herd. This set up gave me a bit The Emperor’s New Groove vibes, which I liked.

I liked reading about these character and especially the character related plot lines and seeing them grow throughout the book. Alya has been a bit sheltered and now that she travels throughout the world she hears of people havign issues with the way the kingdom is governed and hearing their complaints and seeing different sides. While Trill gains in confidence during this journey and realizes how handy her magic can be. There are quite some interesting parts to the story like who the villain is who cursed Alya and why, his motivation makes sense too. There also is the whole part about the magic schools and Alya wanting to change how the kingdom is ruled and slowly growing into her confidence as a princess too.

Next to the bigger plot and adventure there are all these quieter and cozier scenes as well and I thought those were great. I liked seeing Trill and Alya grow closer and be there for each other. There’s even a bit of romance there. There also are some fun side characters along the way like the moth lady they go to for advice. And ofcourse all the goats are so fun to read about and they have their own personality as well.

The artwork was pretty and fit the story well. It was all full color and the story really came to life with the help of the artwork. I liked seeing the different scenery along their adventure. And I liked seeing all the different facial expressions of the characters, the art could convey so much and it was just nice to look at it all.

To summarize: I had a great time reading Goat magic, this was such a fun book. It features two likable characters who grow a lot and learn about themselves along the way. The plot is a fantasy adventure style with a villain who curses one of the main characters, the villain has a solid motive. There is a touch of romance as well. I liked reading about the characters and their adventure and learning about this world. There are lots of fun side characters like the goats and the moth lady. The artwork was beautiful and I liked how the art added to the story, I liked being able to see all the different scenery as well as the character facial expressions. All in all I had a great time reading this one, it’s a fun read and the artwork looks great.