Review: Christmas Cocoa Murder by Carlene O’Connor, Maddie Day and Alex Erickson

Posted September 24, 2019 by Lola in Mystery, Review / 6 Comments

Review graphic

Christmas Cocoa MurderChristmas Cocoa Murder (Irish Village Mystery #4.5) (Country Store Mystery #6.5) (Bookstore cafe’s mystery)
by Carlene O’Connor, Maddie Day and Alex Erickson

My Rating: 4 stars

Genre: Cozy Mystery
Age Category: Adult
Type of romance: MF

‘Tis the season for hot chocolate and mouthwatering treats. But sometimes too much of a good thing can be downright deadly . . .

Siobhán O’Sullivan’s hopes for a quiet Irish Christmas are dashed when the local Santa turns up dead in a carnival dunk tank of hot cocoa. Now instead of hunting down holiday gifts, she’s pursuing a heartless killer. Seems the dead Santa was no angel either, stealing neighborhood dogs to guide his sleigh. But was it his holiday antics—or worse—that led to his death by chocolate?

When local businessman Jed Greenberg is found dead with a Chocolate lab whimpering over his body, the police start sniffing around Robbie Jordan’s country restaurant for answers. Was it something in Robbie’s hot cocoa that killed Jed, or was it Cocoa the dog? As the suspects pile as high as her holiday tree, Robbie attempts to get to the bottom of the sickly-sweet murder . . .

DEATH BY HOT COCOA by Alex Erickson
A Christmas-themed escape game seems like the perfect pre-holiday treat for bookstore café owner Krissy Hancock and her best friend. But when the host is found dead in a pool of hot cocoa, it’s up to Krissy and her team to catch the killer—or escape before getting killed.

There’s nothing like a hot cup of murder to warm up the holiday season!

My Review

I received a free copy of this book from the publisher through Netgalley.

I have to admit that the biggest reason I requested this one was because there’s a novella by Maddie Day in this book. I love her Country Store Mysteries series and I was excited to read her Christmas novella set in that series. I also like discovering new to me authors, so I figured this was a great opportunity to check out the other two stories as well which are by new to me authors.

Christmas Cocoa Murder by Carlene O’Connor
This story is clearly part of an ongoing series, but even so it was quite easy to get a feel for the setting and the characters. There were a few moments that I did notice me being new to this series, like trouble remembering all the character’s names as none of them were familiar it was a bit much to get introduced to so many new to me characters and there was this part where I hadn’t realized some of Siobhán’s siblings were quite a bit younger than her. It also was a bit difficult at first to get the feel for the setting and characters while also following the start of the mystery. But overall I think the author did a good job making this novella accessible for those who don’t know the series.

The mystery got off to a quick start when the village Santa gets murdered. Siobhán doesn’t start her job at the Garda yet till next year, but she gets involved anyway and can help solve the mystery. The mystery was quite a good one. There are some clues that are important and some things I knew were part of the answer, but it still takes a while for things to come together. I wrongly guessed who the murderer was and there was quite the nice twist when everything finally falls on it’s place.

I think I have the first book in this series and definitely plan to go back and read that at some point. I think if you are already familiar with this series this novella will be even more fun. I had some trouble getting a feel for the characters as I didn’t know them beforehand, but even so it was nice following them around as they solve this mystery.

Christmas Cocoa and a Corpse by Maddie Day
This was the story I was most excited about and it really was a great one. I love this series and I really enjoyed spending some time with Robbie and in her store this time set around Christmas. The Christmas theme was a fun addition and I always enjoy seeing the familiar characters.

The mystery wasn’t as complicated as that in most books in this series. With only two main suspects it was relatively easy to solve it and after a certain clue I was sure I knew who the murder was. Even the motive was clear already. I liked how Robbie again took the effort to be careful and not go alone when talking to possible murder suspect.

All in all this was a great short read set in this series. I enjoyed spending time with the characters and have an entertaining read set around Christmas. There also was a cute puppy and some cocoa as well.

Death by Hot Chocolate by Alex Erickson
This was a fun story. I liked the locked room type of mystery in this book. The main character and one of her friends join a escape room and during the escape room someone gets killed. Now they’re stuck in the escape room and one of them is the killer. I thought this was a fun set-up for a mystery. It added some great suspense knowing one of them was the murderer.

I also liked how this set-up lend itself for a shorter read as they have to figure it out before they can escape from the room. Another bonus was that for those new to this series this short story was really easy to get into as it all takes place in the escape room there aren’t many appearances of characters or mentions of things you don’t know. And this story did make me curious about the rest of the series.

The mystery was a pretty good one. It was tricky to figure out who had done it, but before I had a solid guess the main character figured it out. It made sense and I liked how things fell on it’s place. It also was interesting how the motive in this one was quite hard to figure out and even when the main character figured out the who she didn’t know the why until the murderer told them.

To summarize
I really enjoyed this collection with three Christmas themed cozies. Only one of these was in a series I already knew and the other two authors were new to me. I enjoyed all three of the stories, although the one by Maddie Day was my favorite as I already knew that series. The other two have me curious to check out those series too. I also liked how each of the stories had a Christmas theme and hot cocoa played a role in the murder mystery. All in all I would definitely recommend this collection to cozy mystery fans.

4 Stars


You can also read my review on Goodreads, Bookbub and Amazon.

Do you like reading Christmas themed reads?

Tags: ,

6 responses to “Review: Christmas Cocoa Murder by Carlene O’Connor, Maddie Day and Alex Erickson

  1. That’s great that all the stories were good and left you wanting more of the series. I like the sound of the first one, the most, and will have to check it out, but I’ve already wanted to try the Country Store ones after seeing your reviews.
    It’s funny, but I just read a Halloween themed trio of cozy mysteries so I could try the authors and particularly one of them that was recommended. The first story was a little boring, but the other two were good with the one I wanted to read as the best.
    Sophia Rose recently posted…Review: Fallen by Rebecca ZanettiMy Profile

    • It was a fun anthology with enjoyable stories. I hope to check out the two series I haven’t read yet. I hope you get around to reading the Country Store series eventually.

      How fun you just read a Halloween themed trio of cozie reads. It’s a fun way to try new authors.

Leave a Reply to Lola Cancel reply

CommentLuv badge

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.